five ways

five ways
   'The five ways' is a familiar name for the five arguments for the existence of God that Thomas Aquinas presents in Summa Theologiae (Ia, q2, a3). Thomas believes that human reason can come to knowledge of the existence of God by reasoning from the effect to the necessary cause. In the first way he begins with the fact of movement in the world (being in Act), which requires a first mover. In the second way he argues that the existence of efficient causation requires a first efficient cause. According to the third way, things that exist contingently do not exist at all points in time. But then (Thomas claims) if we retroject backwards far enough, we should come to a time when nothing existed. But if there were a time when nothing existed, then, without a necessary being to bring everything into existence, nothing would have ever come to exist. Each of these ways can be seen as a form of the cosmological argument. The fourth way looks to a maximum good as necessary as a standard and ground for the relative finite goods that we experience. This parallels some forms of the moral argument. Finally, the fifth way identifies the ends to which objects in creation work as evidence for a final causal ground of order and design. This final way is a form of the argument to design. Each of these arguments has found its share of criticism. For instance, Thomas's reasoning on the third way is not convincing: why is it impossible that it might have been that at any given time of the past there was at least one contingent entity? Further, Thomas has been critiqued for his easy move from each argument to the conclusion 'and this everyone knows to be God'. Finally, some object that in Thomas these arguments appear like a prolegomenal epistemic justification of theology, but that is to misread him in light of contemporary issues of foundationalism.
   Further reading: Aquinas 1963-80; Jay 1946; Kenny 1969b

Christian Philosophy . . 2015.

Игры ⚽ Нужно решить контрольную?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Five Ways — Five Ways, the …   Philosophy dictionary

  • Five Ways — For the proofs of God s existence by Saint Thomas Aquinas see: *Quinquae viaeThere are two places called Five Ways. *Five Ways, Birmingham *Five Ways, VictoriaAlternatively you might be looking for the school: *King Edward VI Five WaysOr the… …   Wikipedia

  • Five Ways, Birmingham — Five Ways is an area of Birmingham, England. It takes its name from a major road junction, now a busy roundabout (with pedestrian subways through a traffic island) to the south west of the city centre which lies at the outward end of Broad Street …   Wikipedia

  • Five Ways, Sydney — Five Ways is a junction of streets at the heart of Paddington, Sydney, Australia, away from the hustle and bustle of Oxford Street. There are many cafes and bars in the area.At the five intersections are 19th and 20th century shops, including the …   Wikipedia

  • Five Ways, Wiltshire — Five Ways (or Box Five Ways) refers to an intersection of five roads in Wiltshire, England. Five Ways is the area where Bradford Road (the B3109, running north south) intersects with Devizes Road (the A365, running east west), and a smaller road… …   Wikipedia

  • Five Ways railway station — Infobox UK station name = Five Ways manager = London Midland locale = Five Ways borough = Birmingham pte = West Midlands zone = 1 usage0405 = 0.450 usage0506 = 0.480 usage0607 = 0.514 code = FWY platforms = 2 years = 1978 events = Opened years2 …   Wikipedia

  • Five Ways Tower — Infobox building building name = Five Ways Tower caption = building type = Commercial architectural style = structural system = location = Frederick Road, Five Ways, Birmingham, England coordinates =… …   Wikipedia

  • Five ways to save the world — Infobox Film name = Five Ways To Save The World image size = caption = director = Jonathan Barker, Cecilia Hue, Anna Abbott producer = Karen O Connor writer = narrator = starring = music = cinematography = editing = distributor = released = 2006… …   Wikipedia

  • Five Ways —  ; Quinque Viae    This term refers to the five arguments elaborated by Saint Thomas Aquinas (ca. AD 1225 1274) as ways for human reason to prove the existence of God: (1) prime mover, (2) first cause, (3) necessity, (4) unlimited cause, and (5)… …   Glossary of theological terms

  • Five Ways, the — The ways of demonstrating the existence of God formulated by Aquinas (Summa Theologiae, Ia 3: it is important in understanding the significance of these arguments to Aquinas that the entire context stretches from Ia 2 to 11). They are: (1) Motion …   Philosophy dictionary

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”